Internal Control · 2025
In this section9 topics
- Internal Control — Board Opinion1 item
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies2 items
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations2 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions3 items
- Policy & Future Trends2 items
Internal Control — Board Opinion
Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control
The Company realizes and places importance on the internal control system in order to comply with the principles of good corporate governance. From the Audit Committee Meeting No. 1/2025 on 21 February 2025, the Audit Committee assessed the internal control system by asking for information from the Company's management and completed the assessment of the adequacy of the Company's internal control system according to the assessment of the adequacy of the internal control system of the Securities and Exchange Commission, which consists of 5 components:
1. Control Environment
2. Risk Assessment
3. Control Activities
4. Information and Communication
5. Monitoring Activities
The Board of Directors is of the opinion that the Company has provided sufficient internal management and control systems. The management has encouraged employees in the organization to be aware of the importance of internal control by assigning sufficient and appropriate personnel to enable the Company's operations to proceed in accordance with the objectives and comply with relevant laws and regulations and in line with the principles of good corporate governance. In the past year, the Company had no violations of, or non-compliance with, the rules and regulations regarding connected transactions or asset acquisitions or disposals.
In addition, the Company has established an internal audit unit that is independent in monitoring and evaluating internal controls by hiring internal auditor, from external agencies (Outsource) and reporting directly to the Audit Committee.
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| COSO - Enterprise Risk Management Framework (ERM) | The Company has outsourced an internal auditor by appointing P&L Internal Audit Company Limited as the Company's internal auditor, with Mr. Thanabhat Wongwit as the head of internal audit (details about the head of internal audit in Attachment 3) to audit the internal control system and compliance with the system of the Company and its subsidiaries. In 2025, the internal auditor conducted an audit of the Company's internal control system as follows: 1. Human Resource Management, with the following audit scope: • Policy / Guidelines and Work Instructions for human resource management • Organizational structure chart / departmental structure / scope of authority and responsibilities • Executive authority, Approval authority and Signature example • Human Resource Management budget • Recruitment and hiring • Compensation control • Welfare control • Salary control • Operational control • Evaluation • Personnel development • Termination and resignation • Determination of rights to access information • Others The audit results indicate that the Company has complied with the regulations, manuals, policies, and approval authorities established by the Company. Accordingly, the Company has adequate and appropriate internal controls. 2. Expenditure Cycle Management, with the following audit scope: • Policies, regulations and operating procedures • Organizational chart, scope of authority and responsibilities • Authority to act, authority to approve and sample signatures • Controlling budget expenditures • New vendor selection and registration process and annual evaluation of existing vendors • Purchase request process • Purchasing and hiring process • Contracting process • Receiving process • Recording of creditors • Debt payment • Payment check control • Creditor aging analysis • Petty cash control • Control of advances • Bank deposit verification • Input tax • Withholding tax • Determination of rights to access information system data The audit results indicate that the Company and its subsidiaries have made improvements and ensured full compliance with the established regulations and policies across all areas within the audit scope |
Internal Control Deficiencies
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 0 | 7 | 1 |
Deficiency Details
| Period Type | Start Period (YYYY-MM) | End Period (YYYY-MM) | Detail | Progress Status | Corrective Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| month/year Range | 2024-11 | 2024-12 | • Information security aspects of business continuity management
The risk analysis does not cover all IT business impacts.
| Incident no longer subject to action | The Company is in the process of reviewing its enterprise risk management, which is expected to be completed by 30 June 2025. |
| month/year Range | 2024-11 | 2024-12 | • Compliance
The risk analysis does not cover all IT business impacts and software license register is not consistent with current operations.
| Incident no longer subject to action | The Company is in the process of reviewing its enterprise risk management, which is expected to be completed by 30 June 2025. |
| month/year Range | 2024-11 | 2024-12 | • Asset Management
The Hardware Asset Register, the Software License Register, the Service Contract Register, and the Client Computer Register are not consistent with current operations. | Incident no longer subject to action | The various registers are currently being reviewed to be in line with current operations, which is expected to be completed by 31 March 2025. |
| month/year Range | 2024-11 | 2024-12 | • Access Control
No privileged user management policy and process | Incident no longer subject to action | The policy and operating procedures are currently being revised to be in line with current operations, which is expected to be completed by 30 June 2025. |
| month/year Range | 2024-11 | 2024-12 | • Physical and Environmental Security
There was no temperature sensor, humidity sensor, and Uninterruptible Power Supplies (UPS) and the organization of electrical wiring was not in order. | Incident no longer subject to action | The Company is in the process of tidying up the electrical wiring and will conduct a risk assessment regarding the decision to not install Uninterruptible Power Supplies (UPS) and temperature and humidity sensors. It is expected to be completed by 30 June 2025. |
| month/year Range | 2024-11 | 2024-12 | • Operation Security
No performance evaluation of the Company's work system and network system was found. | Incident no longer subject to action | The Company is in the process of preparing a Monitoring Report to review the capabilities of the work system and network system, which is expected to be completed by 30 June 2025. |
| month/year Range | 2024-11 | 2024-12 | • Communication security
No standard process for storing the data of external individuals who request to use the internet system was found. | Incident no longer subject to action | The Company is reviewing the process for requesting internet access from external parties, which is expected to be completed by 30 June 2025. |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
No
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
No
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3160
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
The Audit Committee Meeting No. 1/2025 held on 21 February 2025 resolved to appoint P&L Internal Audit Company Limited to perform the duties of internal auditor of the Company and its subsidiaries by assigning Mr. Thanabhat Wongwit, vice president of operations, as the head of the internal audit unit. The Audit Committee has considered Mr. Thanabhat Wongwit’s qualifications and resolved that he is sufficiently appropriate to perform such duties as he is independent and has experience in internal auditing for more than 10 years (details on the Head of the Internal Audit appears in Attachment 3). In this regard, consideration and approval, appointment, removal, transfer of the Head of Internal Audit of the Company and its subsidiaries must be approved or agreed by the Audit Committee only.
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
Yes
Description
The Company has defined the scope of power, duties and responsibilities of the Audit Committee to consider and approve, appoint, remove and transfer the head of internal audit of the Company and its subsidiaries only through the approval or consent of the Audit Committee.
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Monetary Unit
1000000
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Type of Business | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Orisma Company Limited | Juristic Person | Holding Company | - It is an associate company in which the Company directly holds 20.00% of the shares. - The Company has sent its representatives to serve as directors. | 2025-12-31T00:00 |
| GTI Corporation Company Limited | Juristic Person | Construction services and other related services | - It is an associate company in which the Company directly holds 15.00% of the shares. - The Company has sent its representatives to serve as directors. | 2025-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 0.08 · Necessity: The Company considers the nature of the business, size and complexity of transactions that occur each month which from the standard and price, the Company has already compared the fair price with reference to the market price. · Description: The Company purchased Bulk SMS service from Orisma Technology Company Limited, in order to provide Bulk SMS service to the Company's customers. · As of yesteryear: 0.53 · Nature of transaction: AddTech Hub Public Company Limited ("the Company") purchased Bulk SMS service from Orisma Technology Company Limited, a subsidiary of Orisma Company Limited, in order to provide Bulk SMS service to the Company's customers. · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is a normal business transaction and brings benefits to the business operations of the Group and the service rates are in accordance with general commercial conditions without transfer of interests between the Company and persons who may have conflict. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.38 |
| 33.01 · Necessity: The Company charges interest at the rate of 8% per year and is guaranteed by the directors of GTI and 125,700 common shares of GTI, representing 35.90% of the total number of shares of GTI. · Description: On 15 November 2023, the Company provided financial assistance in the form of a loan of no more than THB 60 million to GTI . The principal and interest were due to be repaid within 1 year and extension period was set for a maximum of 6 months, changing the original repayment deadline from 16 November 2024 to 16 May 2025. Subsequently, the loan repayment period was extended, with the loan being divided into a short-term loan of THB 9 million, repayable by October 2025, and a long-term loan of THB 30 million, to be repaid in installments from November 2025 through September 2029. · As of yesteryear: 64.69 · Nature of transaction: AddTech Hub Public Company Limited ("the Company") provided loans to GTI Corporation Company Limited ("GTI") to repay other current loans with high interest rates and to use as working capital within the business. · Audit committee opinion: The said transaction is a normal business transaction and brings benefits to the business operations of the Group and the loan interest are in accordance with general commercial conditions without transfer of interests between the Company and persons who may have conflict. · As of year before yesteryear: 60.72 |
Policy & Future Trends
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
Approval of related party transactions or connected transactions
The Company has the following measures for approving transactions:
• Related party or connected transactions of small, medium and large sizes that are transactions with normal commercial agreements as previously approved by the Board of Directors, the management will consider and decide.
• Transactions of small and medium sizes that do not comply with normal commercial agreements, the Board of Directors will consider and decide.
• Transactions of large sizes that do not comply with normal commercial agreements, the shareholders' meeting will consider and decide to conduct the transaction.
The criteria for considering the size of the transaction are as follows:
- Small transactions are transactions with a value of less than or equal to 1 million baht or less than or equal to 0.03% of net tangible assets, whichever is higher.
- Medium transactions are transactions with a value of more than 1 million baht but less than 20 million baht or more than 0.03% but less than 3 percent of net tangible assets, whichever is higher.
- Large transactions are transactions with a value of more than or equal to 20 million baht or more than 3% of net tangible assets, whichever is higher.
Future Trends in Related Party Transactions
Related Party Transaction Policy
In order to comply with the good corporate governance policy, the Company deems it appropriate to establish a policy on related party transactions to ensure that transactions are conducted in a proper and appropriate manner in accordance with relevant laws and regulations.
1. Relevant definitions
“Connected transaction” means a transaction between a listed company or a subsidiary and a related person of the listed company or a transaction between a subsidiary and a related person of the subsidiary.
“Agreement to enter into a transaction” means entering into or agreeing to enter into any contract or agreement, whether directly or indirectly, to acquire or dispose of assets, lease or take lease of assets, provide or receive services, provide or receive financial assistance, and issue new securities, including to create rights or waive rights to such actions.
“Connected person” means a person with the authority to control the decision-making of a listed company or a subsidiary, including the following persons:
(1) Executives, major shareholders, persons with controlling power, or persons to be nominated as executives or persons with controlling power of a listed company or a subsidiary, including related persons and close relatives of such persons.
(2) Any juristic person with a major shareholder or a person with controlling power is the following persons of the listed company or subsidiary:
(a) Executives
(b) Major shareholders
(c) Persons with controlling power
(d) Persons to be proposed as executives or persons with controlling power
(e) Related persons and close relatives of persons under (a) to (d)
(3) Any person whose behavior indicates that he is acting as a representative or is under the influence of persons under (1) to (2) in making decisions on policy determination, management or significant operations, or other persons whom the Stock Exchange of Thailand (“Stock Exchange”) deems to have similar behavior.
2. Characteristics of connected transactions
Connected transactions may be divided into 2 types as follows:
(1) When the Company or its subsidiaries conduct transactions with executives, major shareholders, related persons or close relatives of executives or major shareholders
(2) When the Company or its subsidiaries conduct transactions with any juristic person whose major shareholders or controlling persons are executives, major shareholders, controlling persons or persons who will be nominated as executives or controlling persons of the listed company or its subsidiaries, including related persons or close relatives of those persons
3. Types of connected transactions
Connected transactions are divided into 6 types as follows:
(1) Normal business transactions
(2) Transactions supporting normal business
(3) Transactions renting or leasing real estate for no more than 3 years
(4) Transactions related to assets or services
(5) Transactions providing or receiving financial assistance
(6) Other connected transactions other than those in (1) to (5)
4. Prevention of conflicts of interest
The Company places importance on considering various items transparently and beneficially to the Company. Therefore, it places importance on preventing items that may cause conflicts of interest, related transactions or connected transactions, with the following important principles:
(1) Directors and executives must inform about relationships or connected transactions in businesses that may cause conflicts of interest.
(2) Avoid making connected transactions with directors, executives or connected persons that may cause conflicts of interest with the Company. In cases where such transactions are necessary, the connected transactions must be presented to the Audit Committee for consideration and opinion before being submitted for approval to the Board of Directors and/or the shareholders' meeting of the Company (as the case may be) in accordance with the criteria for making connected transactions as determined by the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Securities and Exchange Commission, and in accordance with the principles of good corporate governance.
(3) Executives and employees must comply with the Company's regulations and business ethics, which are important matters that must be strictly adhered to in order for the Company to be trusted and relied upon by all stakeholders, and arrange for the dissemination of information for employee understanding of practices throughout the Company.
5. Criteria and procedures for related party transactions or connected transactions
The Company is aware of its duty to comply with the criteria for related party transactions or connected transactions as announced by the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and the Securities and Exchange Commission. Therefore, the Company has set the criteria and procedures for related party transactions or connected transactions as follows:
• In considering connected transactions, the Company will use the same price criteria and trade agreements as it does with general customers. As for the provision or receipt of financial assistance, it must be necessary and reasonable, must have fair terms and conditions, and provide the Company with maximum benefit.
• In the event that there are no such price criteria for reference, the Company will consider comparing the price of the product or service with external prices under the same or similar conditions.
• The Company may utilize the report of an independent appraiser appointed by the Company to compare the price for important related party transactions to ensure that such price is reasonable and in the maximum benefit of the group of companies.
• Directors, executives, or related persons may conduct transactions with the Company or subsidiaries only after such transactions have been approved by the Company’s shareholders’ meeting, except for transactions that are trade agreements of the same nature that a reasonable person would do with a general contracting party in the same situation with the power to negotiate trade without influence from the status of the director, executive or related person, as the case may be, and is a trade agreement approved by the board of directors or in accordance with the principles approved by the board of directors.
• If the Company has any related party transactions or other connected transactions that fall under the requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Securities and Exchange Commission, the company must strictly comply with such requirements.
• The Company must disclose information on transactions that may have conflicts of interest, connected transactions or related party transactions in accordance with the criteria set by the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Capital Market Supervisory Board and the Securities and Exchange Commission, by disclosing in the annual registration form and annual report or other report forms, as the case may be, and disclosing information on connected transactions to the Stock Exchange of Thailand in accordance with the criteria of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, as well as transactions related to the company in accordance with accounting standards.
• Review connected transactions according to the audit plan, whereby the internal audit unit must report to the Audit Committee and have measures to control, inspect, and supervise random inspections of actual transactions, correctness, and compliance with the contract or policy or conditions specified.
6. Key points to consider when conducting related party transactions or connected transactions
• Reasons and necessity for conducting transactions with connected persons or entities or entities with conflicts of interest
• Reasonableness of price and trade agreements when compared to conducting transactions with other persons
• Opinions of independent appraisers or financial advisors
• The Company's measures to comply with regulations and rules
• The Company has updated information on shareholding proportions, directors, and important information of subsidiaries (if any) and affiliated companies to be current.
7. Approval of related party transactions or connected transactions
The Company has the following measures to approve transactions:
• Small, medium, and large connected or related party transactions that are transactions with normal trade agreements as previously approved by the Board of Directors, the management will consider and decide.
• Small and medium-sized transactions that do not comply with normal trade agreements, the Board of Directors will consider and decide.
• Large transactions that do not comply with normal trade agreements, the shareholders' meeting will consider and decide to conduct the transaction.
The criteria for considering the size of the transaction are as follows:
- Small transaction means transaction with a value less than or equal to 1 million baht or less than or equal to 0.03% of net tangible assets, whichever is higher.
- Medium transaction means transaction with a value more than 1 million baht but less than 20 million baht or more than 0.03% but less than 3% of net tangible assets, whichever is higher.
- Large transaction means transaction with a value more than or equal to 20 million baht or more than 3% of net tangible assets, whichever is higher.
8. Criteria for considering normal business transactions
• Is the transaction nature a normal business operation?
If the related party transaction occurs due to normal business operations, it will be conducted in accordance with the normal business procedures as practiced with other parties. The transaction size and approval will be considered as shown in the Table of Authority. It will be considered whether it is a normal business transaction or supports such normal business, whether the transaction is reasonable, and has the objective to create maximum benefits for the company. The trade agreement should not be different from transactions with general customers or external parties.
• Is the price and terms of the transaction fair?
If the transaction is compared with an unrelated external party, will the price or terms be better?
9. Consideration of price according to general business conditions (as specified by the Stock Exchange of Thailand)
A transaction that complies with general business conditions is a trade condition with a fair price and terms that does not result in a transfer of benefits by:
• It is a price and terms that the Company or its subsidiaries receive or give to the general public.
• It is a price and terms that a related party gives to the general public.
• It is a price and terms that the Company can show that other operators of similar businesses give to the general public.
10. Methods for presenting to the Audit Committee on connected transactions
(1) Connected transactions under the approval authority of the management
In the case of connected transactions under the approval authority of the management, the management will consider and make a decision. The related persons, such as the accounting and finance department, sales department, purchasing department, or related executives, are responsible for considering the various transactions according to the approval process in the regulations and the Company's operating authority. After the management has considered and approved, it must be presented for the Audit Committee to review the reasonableness of the transaction and disclose the transaction in the annual registration form and the Company's annual report. In addition, the interested parties in the connected transaction must not attend the meeting and have no right to vote in the meeting.
(2) Connected transactions under the approval authority of the Board of Directors
In the case of connected transactions that are small and medium-sized transactions that do not comply with normal trading conditions, which are under the approval authority of the Board of Directors, the originating unit must present details of the necessity and reasonableness of the transaction for the Audit Committee to express an opinion on the said transaction before presenting it to the Board of Directors for the transaction. The procedures are as follows:
• The originating unit summarizes the details of the transaction and prepares all relevant information to present to the CEO.
• The CEO assigns the Internal Audit Division or the Secretary of the Audit Committee to coordinate with the Audit Committee to prepare the meeting agenda.
• The Internal Audit Division or the Secretary of the Audit Committee, together with the relevant units, prepares meeting documents, with a summary of the essential content for the Audit Committee to consider.
• When the resolution of the Audit Committee meeting is reached, the Company Secretary compiles it to present to the Board of Directors for consideration and approval to enter into the transaction. In this regard, directors who have a stake in the connected transaction must not attend the meeting and have no right to vote in the meeting.
• The transaction must be disclosed in the annual registration form and annual report of the Company, and the resolution of the Board of Directors meeting must be disclosed to the Stock Exchange of Thailand with the minimum information as specified by the Stock Exchange of Thailand.
(3) Connected transactions under the approval authority of shareholders
In the case of connected transactions under the approval authority of shareholders, the originating unit must present the details, necessity, and reasonableness of the transaction to request the Audit Committee’s opinion before presenting it to the Board of Directors for approval and presenting it to the shareholders’ meeting to consider and approve the transaction, with the following steps:
• The originating unit summarizes the details of the transaction and prepares all relevant information to present to the CEO.
• The CEO assigns the Internal Audit Division or the Secretary of the Audit Committee to coordinate with the Audit Committee to prepare the meeting agenda.
• The Internal Audit Division or the Secretary of the Audit Committee, together with the relevant units, prepares meeting documents, with a summary of the essential content for the Audit Committee to consider.
• When the resolution of the Audit Committee meeting is reached, the Company Secretary compiles them to present to the Board of Directors for consideration and approval of the transaction. In this regard, directors who have a stake in the connected transaction must not attend the meeting and have no right to vote in the meeting.
• When the resolution of the Board of Directors meeting is reached, the Company Secretary must prepare documents to convene the meeting and request approval from the shareholders. There must be sufficient supporting information for decision-making as specified in the criteria of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and the Securities and Exchange Commission. The Company must also list the names and number of shares of connected persons who do not have the right to vote. In this regard, the Company is responsible for calling a shareholders' meeting in accordance with the methods, procedures, and criteria specified by the said regulatory agencies for connected transactions.
• Disclose the transaction in the annual registration form and the Company's annual report, including disclosing various information to the Stock Exchange of Thailand with the minimum information as specified by the Stock Exchange of Thailand for connected transactions.

